Differences between an employment contract and an employment agreement

Home / Labor Law / Employment / Employment contract

Back

Published: 07/08/2016

Reading time: 6 min

0

1239

For an ordinary person, it is not at all shameful to confuse an employment contract and an employment agreement. But when hiring, knowing the differences between these acts can literally decide your fate as an employee.

The thing is that an employment contract and an employment agreement are concepts from different areas of law and they regulate a different range of relations.

• Employment contract - what is it?
• Employment agreement - concept and features
• Differences between an employment contract and an agreement

Legal basis

Unlike an employment contract, the drafting of an employment agreement is regulated by the provisions of the Civil Code. This is due to the specifics of the employment agreement, which is concluded to perform a specific type of work.

In connection with the existing features of such an employment agreement, its regulation is carried out, first of all, using Article 420 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation. In addition, the norms of the specified legal act devoted to the regulation of relations related to the organization of work performance through the conclusion of a work contract or other agreements devoted to various mechanisms for performing work can be additionally used.

The basis for drawing up an employment contract, in turn, is Section 3 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, in particular, Article 57 of this legal act.

Article 45 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. Agreement. Types of agreements (current version)

1. The definition of the concept of agreement emphasizes its regulatory significance, indicating that this is a legal act regulating social and labor relations.

Unfortunately, the legislator failed to consistently implement this idea: in Parts 5 - 7 of Art. 45, when defining the meaning of specific types of agreements, he only mentions the establishment of principles for regulating social and labor relations.

2. An agreement, unlike a collective agreement, is concluded at other levels of social partnership: federal, interregional, regional, territorial. In this case, agreements can be of a general nature and cover all (most) employers and employees of the relevant territorial entity or be sectoral (intersectoral).

3. The agreement is concluded by employers united within an industry, region, or territory. Their interests in collective bargaining are represented by associations of employers and other representatives of employers. In the case where the agreement provides for full or partial financing from the budget (federal, subject of the Russian Federation, local), it must be concluded with the participation of the relevant executive authority or local government authority.

The other party to the agreements are the employees employed by these employers. Employee representatives are the relevant trade unions and their associations.

4. Unlike a collective agreement (see commentary to Article 40), an agreement, along with social and labor relations, can also regulate economic relations. This concept in Art. 45 not disclosed. The practice of concluding agreements makes it possible to highlight the general obligations of the parties to ensure sustainable economic development of a particular industry. Obviously, the relevant provisions can be considered as aimed at regulating economic relations.

5. The agreement must be concluded within the competence of the representatives of the parties and cannot contain provisions that go beyond the powers granted to them. This rule applies mainly to representatives of employers, since they, on behalf of employers, undertake obligations to ensure the working conditions established by the agreement.

Employer representatives must act within the limits of their authority, otherwise the validity of the agreement may be questioned.

6. Agreements, depending on the level and composition of participants, can be general, interregional, regional, territorial, sectoral (intersectoral). At the same time, sectoral (intersectoral) agreements are concluded at the federal, interregional, regional and territorial levels.

Regional laws on social partnership determine the types of agreements concluded in the relevant constituent entity of the Russian Federation and their content. For example, Law of the Republic of Dagestan dated November 15, 2011 N 71 “On social partnership in the Republic of Dagestan” provides for the following types of agreements: republican; republican sectoral (intersectoral); territorial; territorial-sectoral (intersectoral); other agreements (Article 16).

7. Agreements can be bilateral, concluded by employers and trade unions (associations of trade unions), and tripartite, concluded with the participation of executive authorities or local governments. The type of agreement is determined by agreement between representatives of employees and employers. In practice, the bulk of industry agreements at the federal level are made up of bilateral agreements, while regional and territorial agreements, as a rule, are concluded on a tripartite basis.

8. At the choice of the parties, other agreements, for example professional ones, may be concluded.

It should be noted that Part 10 of the commented article provides for the possibility of concluding agreements at any level of social partnership, i.e. in modern conditions, agreements at the local level are also acceptable, but in this case they should be devoted to “separate areas of regulation of social and labor relations.”

Comment source:

Rep. ed. Yu.P. Orlovsky “COMMENTARY ON THE LABOR CODE OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION”, 6th edition ACTUALIZATION

ORLOVSKY Y.P., CHIKANOVA L.A., NURTDINOVA A.F., KORSHUNOVA T.YU., SEREGINA L.V., GAVRILINA A.K., BOCHARNIKOVA M.A., VINOGRADOVA Z.D., 2014

What is an employment agreement?

An employment agreement, as follows from established law enforcement practice, is a special legal act that is concluded not between an employer and an employee, but between a customer and a contractor. At the same time, due to the almost complete lack of regulatory opportunities, from a regulatory and legal point of view, labor agreements represent a rather complex structure in the sphere of regulation of existing labor relations.

At the same time, the ultimate goal of such a document and the work performed on it is the final result, for which the employee will or will not receive remuneration, depending on what the final result will be.

Employment agreement - concept and features

This type of legal acts is not regulated by the labor legislation of the Russian Federation.

Labor agreements are concluded for short-term hired work, and therefore fall within the purview of civil law.

The terms of such acts imply that the performer will carry out certain work and receive a monetary reward only after its completion. In other words, the subject of an employment agreement is not the employee’s work itself, but its result .

Similar agreements are concluded when applying for temporary work (for example, contract work).

This act often ignores the issues of discipline and protection of the rights of the performer; the number of days off and the right to vacation are not determined.

For this reason, an employment agreement is a legal loophole for unscrupulous employers. The drafting of this document should be done with the utmost care. It is of fundamental importance to have a fixed amount of remuneration for the work done.

The employment agreement is as follows:

Employer A instructs Contractor B to perform certain work within a specified period. A undertakes to pay B a certain monetary reward after the work is completely completed.

The state pension co-financing program is a significant contribution to the financial stability of pensioners. Indexation of pensions in 2016 - full information on this topic is located in our article. Unused vacation and its compensation are described in our article.

The main differences between an employment contract and an employment agreement

There are a number of differences between an employment contract and an employment agreement, which are caused by some features of these documents. These differences include:

• parties to the contract being concluded . In accordance with current legislation, when concluding an employment contract, its participants are the employer and the employee. In an employment agreement, the parties are the customer and the contractor;
• The main regulation and key value under an employment contract is the scope of work, regulation of the basic rights and obligations of participants in such a legal act , as well as the fulfillment by the employee of basic rights and obligations, including compliance with the rules of labor discipline. In an employment agreement, what matters, first of all, is the final result, for the achievement of which the assignment and subsequent payment of remuneration occurs;
• The remuneration mechanism is also regulated differently in the employment contract and employment agreement . According to the employment contract, regular wage payments are mandatory, since such a condition is necessarily provided for by the current legislation of the Russian Federation. At the same time, according to the requirements of existing regulations governing labor relations, a mandatory condition is the payment of wages several times a month. According to the employment agreement, payment is made only upon completion of a certain stage of work or the entire complex of specified actions;
• In the employment contract, issues related to the time of work and rest of a particular employee must be fixed . If we are talking about a civil law contract, called an employment agreement, then in such a legal act this issue is not fixed and is not reflected in any way, since compliance with the work schedule is not important in it - the key role is played by the results of the work and the timing of its completion;
• the duration of the employment contract may not be defined , since the employer and employee may agree that their employment relationship should be of unlimited duration. In an employment agreement, the validity period is always specified either in the form of a calendar designation by indicating a specific date, or by indicating the end of a particular stage;
• According to the employment contract, the employee receives a fairly large number of guarantees , for example, payment of sick leave benefits, provision of annual leave. According to the employment agreement, such guarantees are not provided for in any way, and their provision remains entirely at the discretion of the employer;
• on the basis of a signed employment contract, the employer can hire only a limited number of employees , since their number is limited by the staffing table of the employing organization. According to the employment agreement, any number of employees can be hired, since they are not included in the staff;
• There is also a difference regarding existing liability measures between an employment contract and an employment agreement . According to the employment contract, an employee can only be subject to disciplinary action, for example, in the form of a fine. If the damage is caused by an employee who works under an employment agreement, then he will have to pay both the amount of the fine and compensation for the damage caused by his actions. In this case, the percentage of such compensation is determined by the employer at his own discretion;
• When concluding an employment contract, it is mandatory to provide documents confirming the employee’s education and the availability of appropriate qualification standards . When concluding an employment agreement, you will not need to confirm the general level of education - it will only be enough to provide information about whether the potential employee has qualifications that will be sufficient to perform a specific type of work;
• under an employment contract, both employment and termination of employment relations occur over a fairly long period of time . If we are talking about an employment agreement, then both signing and termination occur in shortened periods of time.

Differences in an employment contract

It is important to note that in the case of an employment contract, the direct provisions of the articles of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation apply. They regulate not only the structure of such a document, but also its content.

Certain fundamental points must be present in every employment contract and unquestioningly followed. This list should include:

1. The full name of the company, position and full name of its manager on the one hand, and the full name of the citizen entering into an employment relationship on the other.
2. Documents confirming the authority (identity) of the parties.
3. A clear location for performing the work function.
4. A complete list of labor functions assigned to a citizen. They must correspond to his education, qualifications, and work experience.
5. Due remuneration for work. Typically, the contract specifies the basic remuneration (salary, rate), and all other additional payments are paid on the basis of a collective agreement or local company documents. They are simply referred to in the contract by reference. At the same time, they have no right to set wages below the legally defined level.
6. Labor regime. A newly hired employee must clearly understand when to come to work, the time of the break and the end of the work function. Anything that exceeds this interval must be paid additionally or compensated by other legal means.
7. Compensation and social package. Working conditions can be very different. If they are associated with a harmful effect on the body, the citizen is entitled to appropriate compensation not lower than the level determined by the legislator. A citizen has the right to immediately know about the presence of such factors before starting work. In addition, you need to immediately discuss the social package available in the company in order to avoid misunderstandings in the future.
8. The date from which you must begin performing your duties.

What is more profitable for the contractor?

Both the employment contract and the employment agreement are intended to ensure that the relationship between job seekers and employers is legal.

When answering the question of what exactly is more profitable for the contractor to conclude, one should take into account the fact what exactly the applicant’s goal is: to receive maximum profit or to provide himself with social guarantees and benefits.

As for the employment agreement, here you can not do all the work yourself, but involve third parties for this, thereby receiving maximum income.

The social package that is provided when registering a TD also plays a significant role. For this reason, such a document can have a significant advantage for the applicant, since the company will not only, for example, provide vacation and pay for it, but will also issue compulsory insurance to its employee.

Among other things, sick leave will be accepted and paid.

As for the vehicle, here you can hire other people to perform the work and exclusively control the work process.

Each method has a number of its advantages, and the choice will depend only on the personal characteristics of the applicant.

There are many differences between an employment contract and an employment agreement, which allows the applicant the right to choose the method of concluding the contract. The legislator gives the citizen the right to choose which agreement to conclude.

What is an agreement

The agreement to the employment contract is a certain part of the employment contract, the conclusion of which is provided for by law. An employment agreement is a mandatory element of any employment contract and states the termination, extension or change of conditions.

An agreement between the parties - employer and employee - is drawn up at the moment when the employee is appointed to a new position or will receive a different salary. An additional agreement to the contract is drawn up at the time of termination of the contract and regulates the termination of its validity. The agreement of the parties indicates a change in the previously drawn up employment contract.

Features of working under a contract

It seems, what is the difference between signing an employment contract and an employment agreement? Indeed, in both cases the parties officially establish their relationship. But from a legal point of view there are differences.

Working conditions are determined by the contract. The specifics of its conclusion are regulated by Art. 56 of the Labor Code. The document defines the rights, obligations of the parties, and liability for violation of obligations.

Positions, terms of reference, rest and work time are also established. A person should not leave the office without permission. If an employee is absent during working hours for 4 hours, this is regarded as absenteeism. You must obtain permission from your employer to avoid coming to the office.

Arbitrary wording is not allowed. Everything related to the performance of duties is regulated by the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. It does not matter what a person does all day in the office, since the salary is transferred in any case. Reward does not depend on results.

Important! When an employment contract has been drawn up, a person can safely go on vacation or apply for sick leave. The time will definitely be paid, the social package is guaranteed.

This is what distinguishes a contract from an employment agreement.

IV. Contents of the employment contract

According to Art. 57 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation it certainly indicates:

• FULL NAME. employee and full name of the employing organization;
• information about the documents used to verify the identity of the employee and the employer, if the employer is an individual;
• TIN of the employer (organization or entrepreneur);
• information about the authorized person of the employer who has the right to sign employment contracts, and about the document on the basis of which he acts (for example, “... represented by General Director I. I. Ivanov, acting on the basis of the Charter ...");
• date and place of conclusion of the contract.

The following information is also required:

• place of work;
• position according to the staffing table, profession, specialty, type of work;
• date of the first working day (in the situation of a fixed-term contract - the validity period and the basis for its preparation);
• terms of remuneration (amount of remuneration, dates of payment, allowances, additional payments, bonuses);
• work and rest schedule;
• guarantees and additional payments for work in dangerous or harmful working conditions and a description of these conditions;
• the nature of the work and its conditions (if necessary);
• working conditions;
• guarantees of compulsory social insurance;
• other conditions, if they are provided for by labor legislation.

If any information and/or conditions were not included in the employment contract when it was signed, this does not mean that it is not valid and does not entail its termination.

The missing information is written directly into the contract itself, and the conditions are formalized in an additional agreement or an appendix to it.

Also, the employment agreement may contain additional conditions that do not worsen the rights of employees in comparison with current labor legislation.

For example:

• about clarification of the place of work;
• about the probationary period;
• on non-disclosure of information protected by law;
• if training was carried out at the expense of the employer, then a period of compulsory service may be indicated;
• conditions for additional support measures (insurance, social welfare, non-state pension provision);
• responsibilities included in local regulations or a collective agreement.

Nuances of registration under the agreement

Expert opinion

Kuzmin Ivan Timofeevich

Legal consultant with 6 years of experience. Specializes in the field of civil law. Member of the Bar Association.

The law does not contain the concept of “employment agreement”. When they say “Employment Agreement,” they mean work under a service contract.

Such cooperation is distinguished by the fact that it is regulated by Chapter 39 of the Civil Code. The law determines the differences between contracts.

In the GPC agreement, the parties independently determine the terms of the transaction. There are three main conditions:

• subject of the transaction;
• term of provision of services;
• price.

Remuneration is paid only on the condition that the duties are fulfilled. If the services are provided poorly, the customer may not accept the work. The liability of the parties is determined by the Civil Code.

For the performer, the difference is that there is no need to adhere to a specific schedule. The main thing is to complete the task efficiently and on time.

There are also differences from an employment contract. Vacation and sick leave are not paid under a service contract. Social guarantees are not provided to the same extent as under the Labor Code of the Russian Federation.

Features of the employment agreement

Based on the differences listed above from an employment contract, an employment agreement is characterized by a number of its own features:

• the document is concluded for a limited period of time , which is completed together with the completion of the work provided for in such an agreement;
• the procedure for concluding and terminating an employment contract is in no way regulated from the point of view of current legislation (if we talk about the algorithm for concluding and terminating this document);
• payment is made only upon completion of the work provided for in the contents of the document , and the amount of payment directly depends on the volume of the foreseen that was actually completed by the hired employee;
• the employer's requirement of all documents confirming education is illegal , since only those documents must be provided that confirm qualifications for the specific type of work performed.

Summary

1. The work performed under an employment agreement and a contract differs.
2. The content of the work, the procedure for paying remuneration, and there are other differences. Personal character is established for labor relations. According to civil law, the contractor may involve other persons in the work.
3. Both documents are aimed at formalizing cooperation between the two parties.
4. If a substitution of agreements is discovered, the court will re-qualify the agreement.

If you need benefits and a social package, it is better to register under the Labor Code. When it is important to receive compensation for services, a service contract is quite suitable.

Some employment relationships that arise between two parties do not fit into the standard framework. However, this does not mean that they are not legal and cannot be concluded. Such relationships are subject to other legal norms and are achieved by drawing up employment agreements.

An employment agreement is a special legal form of relationship, which implies the presence of bilateral obligations, but does not imply such a complex structure as a contract.

Types of agreements

There are certain types of agreements, the form of which is different: general, interregional, regional, sectoral, territorial, additional agreement.

Labor legislation also provides for the following types of agreements, depending on the number of participants:

• double sided;
• tripartite agreement.

The additional agreement and its type are determined during negotiations between the employee and the employee. In this case, an application is provided, a sample and deadlines are observed.

An additional agreement to the employment contract is concluded after negotiations between the parties, during which all interests are taken into account and the application is drawn up on time. Each employment agreement differs in purpose, which affects the procedure, sample, term and type to which the employment agreement and the corresponding application correspond.

A tripartite agreement is concluded with the obligatory participation of responsible state executive authorities, or a tripartite agreement is concluded in the presence of local government bodies of a municipal scale. In this case, a statement is provided and a specific one must be followed by a deadline and a sample

Advantages and disadvantages

The employer can see the positive aspects of using this type of interaction when hiring a team, which will not require him to constantly monitor the activities of builders (other specialists).

Payment will be made upon high-quality completion of the work, after which mutual settlements will be carried out. This form of relationship does not provide for vacation pay and sick leave , which makes it possible to save some money.

If certain duties are not fulfilled or performed poorly, the employer has the right not to pay wages , including through the court or on the basis of the law on consumer rights. These categories of persons are dismissed without any special legal consequences for the employer.

Often this type of relationship attracts unreliable or unscrupulous partners, since penalties for this type of hiring are more than difficult to regulate and impose.

By entrusting urgent and important work to such a partner, you may find yourself in a difficult situation if it involves obligations to third parties.

The positive aspects for hired workers (specialists) are that the procedure requires a minimum of provided documentation, characteristics and confirmation of qualifications .

Getting a job, as well as dismissal upon completion, is done quickly.

This gives you the opportunity to manage your time and adjust to receiving orders at your discretion. Since the work schedule is flexible, it is convenient to manage the schedule.

Expert opinion

Kuzmin Ivan Timofeevich

Legal consultant with 6 years of experience. Specializes in the field of civil law. Member of the Bar Association.

Negative can be called the meager guarantees received from the hiring person. Dismissal can follow at the slightest violation, when the claim for severance pay will have to be defended in court, without a guarantee of recognition of the claim.

If an illness occurs, you will have to adjust the delivery time of services or disrupt them, which can lead to a breakdown in relationships . It’s even worse if the work depends on the supply of resources from the customer or third parties.

The employee will have to engage in organizational activities that are not his responsibility, or take risks .

Model employment contract for micro-enterprises

In addition to the contract itself, the labor relations of the parties are regulated by local (internal) regulations. This is a regulation on wages, bonuses, work and rest schedules, internal regulations and other documents.

A micro-enterprise - an organization or individual entrepreneur with an annual income of no more than 120 million rubles and a number of employees of no more than 15 people - has the right to refuse to accept these acts in whole or in part. But at the same time, the employment contract with the employee must contain those mandatory norms that are usually included in local acts.

To make it easier for small enterprises to maintain personnel documentation, the Government has developed a standard form of agreement, which already includes the necessary provisions. When signing a standard contract, the employee simultaneously confirms that he is familiar with the working conditions, has undergone training in labor safety and agrees to the processing of personal data.

A typical employment contract is a lengthy document of 11 pages. It provides for different conditions of daily routine and remuneration. For example, in paragraph 9.1. There are several sub-items that must be completed only for remote work.

Does the employer have the right to change the standard form of the employment contract, excluding clauses that are not relevant to a specific employee? In letter dated June 30, 2021 No. 14-1/B-591, the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection responded that this is possible. And when filling out the contract, you can remove from the text the points indicated in the notes.

Definition of terms

During the period of validity of the predecessor of the Labor Code until February 1, 2002, the Labor Code, an employment contract was identified with an employment agreement with an employee, concluded by the employer bilaterally. In addition, according to Article 15 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation, contract and employment contract were considered synonymous; the difference was not recorded so much that the word “contract” was written in parentheses after the definition of contract.

The articles of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation do not contain the concept of what an employment agreement and contract are. Therefore, formalizing relations according to these formulations requires a careful reading of the documents with an in-depth understanding of the essence of the definition from the point of view of the correct application of the formulations from a legal point of view.

Contract literally translated from Latin means deal. According to the logic following from the definition, this is a document with more stringent conditions compared to a contract, limiting the actions of the signatory parties. Differences in wording allow you to draw up documents and file a claim in court, bypassing a number of instances.

An employment agreement is also understood as an addition to existing agreements to change the range of conditions relating to a bilateral agreement up to the termination of relations as a result of mutual consensus.

Types of employment contracts

In most cases, a contract with employees is concluded for an indefinite period, that is, it does not stipulate the expiration of the document. It also happens that the contract specifies the period of its validity; this depends on the nature of the work or the conditions under which it is performed. Filling out such a document is discussed in detail in Part 1 of Art. 59 Labor Code of the Russian Federation.

According to the validity period, they are divided into those concluded for an indefinite period and those concluded for a definite period (no more than 5 years).

A fixed-term employment contract will become indefinite if, after the expiration of the period specified in it, the employee continues to work. In this case, the document will be considered issued for an indefinite period. Therefore, there is no need to conclude a new, open-ended agreement. However, an open-ended contract can become a fixed-term one; to do this, you need to terminate the previous contract and draw up a new one indicating its validity period. Such manipulations will need to be justified, Art. 59 Labor Code of the Russian Federation.

Based on the nature of working relationships, the following types can be distinguished:

• at the main place of work;
• for internal and external part-time work (part-time work is impossible without concluding an employment contract, this is the main condition for this type of employment);
• temporary work (work at a seasonal enterprise for less than 2 months, if it is necessary to replace an employee on sick leave);
• short-term contract;
• with employees performing work remotely;
• state (municipal) service.

Please take into account the fact that the Labor Code of the Russian Federation and regulatory legal acts related to labor relations do not apply to certain categories of citizens, provided that they are not employers or their representatives:

• military personnel on duty;
• persons working under civil contracts;
• other persons established by Federal Law (Article 11 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation).

Depending on the legal status of the employee, the contract can be concluded:

• with minor citizens;
• with persons performing family responsibilities;
• with foreigners;
• with persons who do not have citizenship.

According to the nature of working conditions, they are divided as follows:

• normal working conditions;
• possibility of employment at night;
• work in the regions of the Far North and in territories equivalent to them;
• working under hazardous working conditions.

An employment contract can be drawn up at the main place of work, or maybe part-time. In the first case, the employee works full-time at a full-time rate. This is where he keeps his work book, unless the employee refuses to keep it on paper.

In the second case, the employee works part-time in his free time from his main job. This work cannot last more than four hours a day. The document signed with the employee indicates that the work being performed is part-time. It is not allowed to conclude such contracts with persons under 18 years of age, as well as with those whose main work is classified as difficult or is performed in hazardous working conditions, if the combination of jobs involves working in the same conditions. But we have already written about this.

The contracts concluded with managers and chief accountants deserve special attention. When compiling them, you need to take into account a number of nuances, in comparison with other categories of workers. We’ll talk about drawing up an employment contract with the chief accountant in my next article.

When is it concluded?

Employment agreements include the following possible options:

contract: for repair work (Article 702 of the Civil Code);

Civil Code of the Russian Federation Article 702. Contract

1. Under a contract, one party (contractor) undertakes to perform certain work on the instructions of the other party (customer) and deliver the result to the customer, and the customer undertakes to accept the result of the work and pay for it.
2. For certain types of contract (household contract, construction contract, contract for design and survey work, contract work for state needs), the provisions provided for in this paragraph apply, unless otherwise established by the rules of this Code on these types of contracts.

Civil Code of the Russian Federation Article 730. Household contract

1. Under a domestic contract, the contractor carrying out the relevant business activity undertakes to perform, on the instructions of the citizen (customer), certain work designed to satisfy the household or other personal needs of the customer, and the customer undertakes to accept and pay for the work.
2. A household contract is a public contract (Article 426).
3. Laws on the protection of consumer rights and other legal acts adopted in accordance with them apply to relations under a household contract that are not regulated by this Code.

Civil Code of the Russian Federation Article 758. Contract agreement for design and survey work

Under a contract for design and survey work, the contractor (designer, surveyor) undertakes, on the customer’s instructions, to develop technical documentation and (or) perform survey work, and the customer undertakes to accept and pay for their results.

When is an employment contract concluded?

What is an employment contract and when is it concluded? From the name itself it follows that this is an agreement between the parties who have entered into an employment relationship. The characteristics of these relations are given in Article 15 of the Labor Code of the Russian Federation:

• personal performance by an employee of a certain labor function for payment;
• management and control of the employer;
• subordination of the employee to internal labor regulations;
• provision by the employer of working conditions and creation of a workplace.

Free consultation on business registration
If you hire a contractor to perform a certain amount of services or work that he performs independently, then this relationship is called civil law.

An employment contract with an employee maximally protects the rights of hired personnel and imposes a number of obligations on the employer. The Labor Code of the Russian Federation devotes a separate section to this document.

The employee and employer must enter into a written agreement within three working days from the start of work. But even if the agreement, as a document, was not signed during this period, it is considered that upon the actual admission of the employee to perform his duties, the parties entered into an employment relationship.

Article 5.27 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation provides for a special sanction for the absence or improper execution of an employment contract in the form of a fine:

• for individual entrepreneurs - from 5 to 10 thousand rubles;
• for officials - from 10 to 20 thousand rubles;
• for legal entities - from 50 to 100 thousand rubles.

For the employer

The main advantage is that hired employees strive for the final result on their own. They do not need to be constantly monitored, since payment is made upon completion of the service.

The employer should not incur additional expenses related to social guarantees: payment of sick leave, regular vacations. This saving is considered a significant positive aspect in such relations. Also, the employer does not pay any taxes for such employees.

The downside may be that the performers will be unreliable and irresponsible. The planned volume will not be fulfilled on time. Especially if this concerns obligations to third parties.

Penalties can only be applied to such employees through the courts.

For an employee

The positive aspect is the speed of placement and dismissal. A minimum number of documents are required to conclude an employment agreement. The work can be done at any convenient time, the main thing is to meet the deadline specified in the document.

One of the disadvantages for the contractor is the lack of guarantees. Dismissal may follow even if you become ill. The time spent on performing certain activities under an employment agreement is not counted towards length of service and is not taken into account for calculating future pensions.

How to apply?

Registration of civil legal relations is carried out by drawing up a document in writing in two copies, which are signed by the parties.

The document indicates the participants in the concluded relationship: the customer and the contractor. The subject of the relationship, which is either work or a service provided, is also described.

Mandatory clauses of the document are clauses on payment (Article 709 of the Civil Code) and the deadline (Article 708 of the Civil Code) for completing the scope of work, as well as the procedure for making payment. When drawing up the document, it is necessary to provide for the possibility of early termination of the relationship.

Civil Code of the Russian Federation Article 708. Time frame for completing work

1. The work contract specifies the start and end dates for the work. By agreement between the parties, the contract may also stipulate deadlines for completing individual stages of work (interim deadlines). Unless otherwise established by law, other legal acts or provided for by the contract, the contractor is responsible for violation of both the initial and final, as well as intermediate deadlines for the completion of work.
2. The initial, final and intermediate deadlines for completing the work specified in the contract may be changed in cases and in the manner provided for by the contract.
3. The consequences of delay in performance specified in paragraph 2 of Article 405 of this Code occur when the deadline for completing the work, as well as other deadlines established by the contract, is violated.

Upon completion of the work, a transfer and acceptance certificate must be issued for the civil document

Main differences

At first glance, it may seem that there is no difference which document to sign, because the registration is carried out officially. But in fact, there are fundamental differences between them. Before signing a contract, you need to clarify what the difference is.

1. Name of the parties. The Labor Code of the Russian Federation calls the parties employee and employer. Civil legislation contains the terms customer and contractor.
2. Subject of agreement. The employee systematically performs his duties throughout the working day (shift). The performer works for results.
3. Method of performing duties. The employee performs duties in person by coming to the office. Under the GPC contract, you can attract other persons to work. Subcontract agreements are concluded.
4. Payment order. The employee receives remuneration for his work twice a month. The contractor receives remuneration in the order specified in the document.
5. Social package. Vacation and sick leave are paid if a person is registered under the Labor Code of the Russian Federation. According to the GPC agreement, only the services themselves are paid for.

Duties of the parties

If an employment contract is drawn up, the employee undertakes to comply with the internal rules and daily routine. In return, the employer undertakes to pay regularly agreed wages, provide vacation, weekends and holidays, and pay for periods of absence due to illness.

If we are talking about work under an employment agreement, then the citizen has no such obligations. He does not have to obey the internal work schedule, but in return he will not receive social benefits or regular wages.

Expert opinion

Kuzmin Ivan Timofeevich

Legal consultant with 6 years of experience. Specializes in the field of civil law. Member of the Bar Association.

He will only receive payment for the work performed, and then after signing the acceptance certificate, that is, after the “Customer” accepts these works.

The only thing that the “Contractor” is obliged to comply with are the safety rules for carrying out work, in turn, the “Customer” is obliged to provide instructions to the first one.

If working conditions, wages change, or if an office or warehouse is moved to another location, an additional agreement to the employment contract must be concluded with the employee. Although this sign rather unites the transactions.

In an employment agreement, the parties must also enter into an additional agreement and change previously reached agreements. The main thing is that in both cases, both parties agree to the changes.

According to the employment contract, the employee undertakes to perform the work personally. If we are talking about a civil transaction, then unless otherwise provided by the contract, the “Executor” has the right to delegate the execution of the contract to another person.

What are the differences from an employment contract?

An employment agreement and an employment contract are not the same concepts. There is a significant difference that you should be aware of.

It is important for the employer to formalize agreements with the employee in the correctly chosen format; accounting and tax accounting, relations with the tax inspectorate, and taxation of the enterprise as a whole will depend on this.

An employment contract is an agreement on a voluntary basis between an employer and an employee, on the basis of which one party undertakes to provide the other with work, decent working conditions, payment of wages, etc.

The employee must fulfill his job duties and obey the internal regulations of the enterprise. These relations are regulated by labor legislation.

In civil law relations, the employee independently plans time costs and work schedule . He personally bears all the main risks for the loss of the final result, the finished product, regardless of the reason, and has no right to demand remuneration for the work done without completing it in full and on time.

From the video you will learn how an employment contract differs from a civil law one:

Subject of the transaction

If an employment contract is being drawn up, the subject of such an agreement is the process itself. When concluding an agreement, the main thing is the material result of the service or work.

In practice, many workers manage to not produce any results and stay at work for a long time, receiving wages. In the case of concluding a civil law transaction, this will not work, since payment will still be made after receiving the result that should be received by the “Customer” in the end.

Signing and renewal of the agreement

Signing an agreement is possible if the interests of all parties are taken into account after the negotiation stage. For this purpose, an application and a special sample are provided, the form of which is determined by law. The agreement must be signed by all parties to the case and participants in the relevant negotiations. To do this, it is necessary to negotiate the upcoming conclusion of an agreement, which must be carried out within three months.

The agreement between employer and employee can be renewed on time. To do this, you need to comply with the legal order. In this case, an additional agreement to the employment contract is concluded. This document also provides a sample, filling procedure, writing an application and is drawn up according to the same standards as the employment agreement:

• provided in writing within a certain period of time;
• undergoes state registration of agreements;
• the agreement between the parties is notarized.